200 Hotels in Scotland 
 
 
 
    
  
You Are Here : ScotlandBy.Com > Accommodations > Gilmerton > Melville Castle Hotel
  
   
   
  
 

Traveler Reviews for Melville Castle Hotel


Melville Gate, Gilmerton Road, Edinburgh, EH18 1AP
 
 


 
  
 
Judge yourself!
Look at the
68 photos
taken by our photographer!
Guest Rating

 
84%
35 guests and 3 review
Selected for you!
We have personally
visited and selected
it for you in 2005!*

Travellers Reviews


Submitted by Trevor Hughes, Shrewsbury, United Kingdom

Warning - to the 'poor but wanting something special' - the hotel is gorgeous - we loved it - but the evening meal is expensive - 30 pounds per person - we ate chocolate in our room as the budget didn't stretch that far!
Rating 81%
Submitted by Anonymous

The guest has left no specific comment, however has rated the overall satisfaction rate with a 100% score, his arival experience with a 100% value and his check-out with a 89% rate.
Rating 97%
Submitted by Anonymous

We were disappointed with the showers. They were cold every morning, no hot water.
...
Cold Showers!
...
Cold Showers
...
Cold Showers
...
great but cold showers
Rating 75%

The reviews within this page do not necessarily reflect the views of WorldBy.Com.
  
  
   
Home | Legal Disclaimer